Supply Tie vs McMaster-Carr: Packaging & MRO Price Comparison
Short answer: Supply Tie and McMaster-Carr both sell packaging and MRO supplies to businesses. In a spot check of 4 common items on Oct 30, 2026, Supply Tie was lower on hand stretch wrap, disposable nitrile gloves and case-pack clear packing tape, and McMaster-Carr was lower on 55 gallon trash bags (with a thinner bag). Supply Tie carries 150,000+ SKUs, ships to the lower 48 states and DC, and offers Net 30 to approved business accounts. Want your own list compared? Get a free bulk price check.
Price comparison (as of Oct 30, 2026)
| Item | Supply Tie | McMaster-Carr |
|---|---|---|
| Hand stretch wrap, 18 in. x 1,500 ft., 80 gauge, 4 rolls | $64.96/case of 4 ($16.24/roll) | Part 2008T262: $101.10/pkg. of 4 ($25.28/roll) |
| Clear packing tape, 2 in., natural rubber adhesive, case of 36 | 2 in. x 110 yd: $176.30/case ($4.90/roll) | Part 76255A174, 2 in. x 330 ft (110 yd): $345.72/case ($9.60/roll) |
| Trash bags, 55 gal, black, 100 bags | 44–55 gal, 1.25 mil: $58.76/case of 100 | Part 4166T67, 55 gal, 1 mil, twist ties: $47.35/pkg. of 100 |
Prices are list (web) prices shown on supplytie.com and mcmaster.com on Oct 30, 2026, before shipping and tax, not signed in. Both can change, and items are similar but not identical (for example, McMaster-Carr's glove is 3 mil vs. 3.5 mil, and its trash bag is 1 mil vs. 1.25 mil). McMaster-Carr is a trademark of McMaster-Carr Supply Company; Supply Tie is not affiliated with McMaster-Carr.
Where McMaster-Carr wins
- Lower price on 55 gallon trash bags in this check (a thinner 1 mil bag).
- A very deep catalog of specialty industrial parts, with detailed specs and CAD drawings.
- Small single packs of many items when you only need one.
How Supply Tie works
| Supply Tie | |
|---|---|
| Founded | 2023 |
| Catalog | 150,000+ SKUs |
| Ships to | Lower 48 states and DC |
| Ship time | Poly bags, boxes and MRO usually ship in 1–2 business days; most orders arrive 2–4 business days later. Other items vary by vendor. |
| Pricing | Bulk and pallet pricing on volume orders |
| Terms | Net 30 for approved business accounts |
| Price check | Free line-by-line price check on your current list |
For McMaster-Carr's current terms, shipping and policies, check its website directly.
When Supply Tie is a good fit
- You buy stretch wrap, gloves, tape or liners by the case or pallet and want to compare landed cost.
- You want Net 30 terms on business orders.
- You want bulk and pallet pricing on repeat packaging and MRO orders.
More: McMaster-Carr alternative · 18 in. hand stretch wrap by the case · nitrile gloves by the case · Supply Tie vs Grainger · Supply Tie vs Global Industrial
Send your McMaster-Carr list for a free price check
Questions? support@supplytie.com · 812-639-2943.
Supply Tie, LLC · 3861 E Schnellville Rd, Saint Anthony, IN 47575 · Pickup by appointment · Mon–Fri 8–4 ET
Ships nationwide to the lower 48 + DC · support@supplytie.com · 812-639-2943
FAQ
Is Supply Tie cheaper than McMaster-Carr?
On some items, yes. In a spot check on Oct 30, 2026, Supply Tie's 18 in. x 1,500 ft. 80 gauge hand wrap was $16.24 a roll vs. $25.28 a roll at McMaster-Carr (part 2008T262), and 2 in. clear rubber-adhesive tape was $4.90 a roll vs. $9.60 a roll (part 76255A174). McMaster-Carr was lower on 55 gallon trash bags: $47.35 per 100 for a 1 mil bag (part 4166T67) vs. $58.76 per 100 for Supply Tie's 1.25 mil bag. Shipping is not included in either price, so compare your landed cost.
Where does McMaster-Carr win?
McMaster-Carr was lower on 55 gallon trash bags in this check, and it has a very deep catalog of specialty industrial parts with detailed specs and CAD drawings.
Does Supply Tie offer Net 30?
Yes. Supply Tie offers Net 30 terms to approved business accounts, plus bulk and pallet pricing on volume orders.
How fast does Supply Tie ship?
Supply Tie ships to the lower 48 states and DC. Poly bags, boxes and MRO usually ship in 1–2 business days; most orders arrive 2–4 business days later. Other items vary by vendor.
Can Supply Tie price my McMaster-Carr list?
Yes. Send your current list through the free price check at supplytie.com/pages/price-check and Supply Tie will price it line by line.